22- INTEGRATED BUSINESS PLANNIN (IBP)
· What is “Integrated Business Planning” (IBP)?
IBP
is a process for aligning a company’s business goals with its finance, supply
chain, product development, marketing and other operational functions.
IBP
aligns business goals and financial targets with decisions and execution across
the entire business.
·
What is “Sales and Operations Planning” (S&OP)?
Sales
and operations planning (S&OP) is an integrated planning process that
aligns demand, supply, and financial planning and is managed as part of a
company’s master planning. S&OP is designed and executed to support
executive decision-making related to approving a feasible and profitable
material and financial plan.
·
What are the similarities between IBP and S&OP?
Mention and describe them.
It is clear and obvious that S&OP and IBP processes
have many similarities: Both require supporting data, which helps to align
forecasts with functions and guide managers to make planning decisions.
To successfully implement the S&OP or the IBP, it is
imperative to pay attention to a series of steps to follow in order to achieve
the expected results, simply because they are tools highly developed to ensure
the efficiency of the Supply Chain.
·
What are the differences between IBP and S&OP? Mention
and describe them.
The big difference between IBP and S&OP is that the
latter has become the domain of supply chain and logistics specialists,
particularly those involved in supply-and-demand balancing and planning.
S&OP is execution-focused and involves a traditional budgeting process.
In contrast, IBP takes a more cross-functional and
holistic approach to weaving business goals through every function. As a
result, in theory, supply chain management is proactive and optimized.
IBP includes S&OP processes but because it involves
cultural change, without executive buy-in, IBP will not be successful.
·
How does the IBP process work? Describe in detail.
1. Determine what is holding the company back. Is it a
lack or growth or profitability? Is the product portfolio too complex? Has the
business lost competitiveness in its space? For our manufacturing firm, the
main problem was overfocus on one niche market.
2. Engage and educate employees. Once leadership buys in
to goals, that enthusiasm must trickle down through the ranks. Unless everyone
is committed to integrated business planning, success will be elusive. The COO
recognizes that a formal employee engagement program will keep workers invested
in the success of the business and actively working to meet strategic goals.
3. Set up a tiger team. IBP success comes from tight
coordination, constant communication and accountability . It’s a cultural shift
that will take time to propagate throughout the business.
4. Establish a project/product prioritization process. IBP
takes discipline. Only projects that forward the company’s strategic goals get
resources. Same for products. That might mean sunsetting a line that’s still
selling but lacks growth potential. All managers who require resources or have
a product or service launch idea fill out a cost-benefit analysis template that
is tailored to reveal whether expected benefits and costs align with goals.
Leadership prioritizes using this process.
5. Expand the finance team’s influence. Finance needs to
sit in on product planning, supply chain optimization and sales strategy
meetings. So the head of finance assigns an accounting team member who knows
the business and has an aptitude for data collection and number crunching.
6. Adopt technology and tools to support IBP. If the
forecasting process is seen as a quarterly or annual exercise imposed by
finance and yielding little benefit to departments, IBP can’t succeed.
Companies with static, point-in-time budgets need to adopt rolling forecasts to
make sure the business stays on track. And, finance teams need to be able to
easily access the data they need from each operational area. Both rolling
forecasts and better use of data require technology and a commitment to
transparency. You can’t manage what you can’t measure.
·
What are the challenges of IBP?
Challenges
:
Working
to eliminate unplanned events (often known as ‘fighting fires’ in our
day-to-day work lives) that are caused by a lack of focus on detail in the plan
itself.
Building
trust across different business functions, especially in larger organisations.
Demonstrating the benefits of sharing plans can be a difficult task.
Correctly
managing product lifecycles, and a willingness to take them out of the product
portfolio when they are no longer contributing to the bottom line.
Not
utilising complex ERP systems when they are available.
·
Which are the most common difficulties/problems when
implementing IBP? Mention them and
provide examples.
1) No
Executive Engagement
IBP
done right is going to require hard decisions about risk mitigation and
margins, for example, that leadership can’t delegate and can’t dodge;
When it gets difficult you’ll need to rely on the power of the
hierarchy to move forward.
2)
Poor or Non-Existent Data Governance
IBP
will expose data silos and data turf wars, as well as multiple definitions for
seemingly straightforward concepts like “forecast” and “demand.” Be prepared to
work hard developing a single source of truth. Turning a world of data into a
data-driven world depends on many things, including firm definitions and roles.
3) No
Clear Goals
Companies
jump into planning without answering these three questions:
What
is the goal of your S&OP process?
How
do you make decisions?
What
do you measure?
Each
phase builds on what comes before. Usually, after failing, companies find that
they must first be able to execute “what if” analyses to determine a feasible
plan before attempting to match demand with supply. And that mastering the process of matching
demand with supply is a prerequisite to successful IBP.
4) No
Cross-Functional Collaboration, Lack of Focus on Data Model and Analytical Plan
Inability
to translate among different functional views of information can be alienating,
especially in the early stages when buy-in might be fragile. Sales inputs
revenues by account, Operations may want to see demand in units by product, and
Finance is interested in margin. Ideally, the same information should be
tailored to stakeholders in a manner they understand.
5)
IBP Gets Positioned as an IT Project
IBP
can’t be viewed as a module that your ERP provider can license to you or a new
report that IT could write for you if they had time. It must be positioned and
even revered as radical, transformative, permanent, and worth the effort.
6)
The Role of the Budget is Undefined
Many
industry experts believe the key change management issue for IBP is wrangling
the role of the budget. Some companies
treat the budget as sacrosanct. As a result, they constrain the outcome of IBP
to ensure that budget goals are met.
7)
Poor Setting of Expectations
The
entire contemplation is far-reaching and complex. Don’t strive for “one number”
anything. Some companies spend months deriving a single “guiding” number that
is so massaged and scrubbed that the only thing you can be sure of is its
inaccuracy. Others paralyze themselves trying to evaluate hundreds of metrics.
Most
IBP projects eventually uncover incentives at cross purposes. It could be Sales
and quota credit versus Operations and customer satisfaction.
·
What are the advantages and disadvantages of IBP?
Advantages:
·
Profit improvements
·
Reduced working capital expenses
·
Optimization of logistics, capacity, procurement, supply
and demand all with the use of a single planning solution
·
Improved cross-functional collaboration, planning agility,
risk mitigation, and forecast accuracy
·
Reduced planning timeframes from weeks or months to just a
few days or hours.
·
Increased stakeholder value for the company, at large
·
Broader trust in plans
Disadvantages
·
Errors handling.
· Needs more data entry flexibility.
·
What is the importance of IBP nowadays?
By enhancing
the decision-making ability of IBP, it can be regarded as an effective tool to
help companies overcome the challenges they face. In fact, IBP is seen as the
best practice and method that combines the financial and operational data of
the entire organization. Indeed, by linking strategic plans with sales,
operations, and financial plans, it can enable companies to maximize output and
thus better understand the relationship between resources, capabilities, and
results.
Bibliography
https://www.oracle.com/scm/what-is-sales-operations-planning/
https://www.scmdojo.com/sop-vs-ibp/
https://www.sixdegreesexecutive.com.au/blog/2014/10/ibp-challenges-and-best-practice
https://www.logility.com/es/blog/why-do-integrated-business-planning-initiatives-fail/
https://www.riverlogic.com/blog/what-is-integrated-business-planning
I agree, if a company does not have clear goals, it is difficult to succeed. In this case I think the most difficult thing would be to establish goals that benefit all the departments involved since everyone has a voice in the process of planning.
ResponderBorrarFor the IBP to work, the company must first know what it wants so that it can decide what to do and start planning. In addition, part of the planning is to know the function of each department
ResponderBorrarI agree with you about your definition of IBP, we kind of came up with a very similiar definition.
ResponderBorrarDo you think that every company can implement an IBP? On the other hand, I agree with you on the importance of IBP however I believe that the company that runs it has to have a previous organization that goes through this process.
ResponderBorrari like the way that you describes all points, you provide very good material.
ResponderBorrar
ResponderBorrarI agree with your answers, they are concise and have clear information